This simple French dish is why summer tomatoes are made
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/20250725-TartealaTomate-AmandaSuarez-08-351105f2329941389f8beedf02f21e2c.jpg?w=780&resize=780,470&ssl=1)
Why it works
- This recipe is very flexible and can work with a variety of crusts (puff pastry, pie crust, shortcrust pastry) and formats (pie pan, pie plate, free shape pan).
- Just a few key ingredients – tomatoes, mustard, cheese and pastry – combination for a summer snack which is much more than the sum of its parts.
It is easy to launch superlatives with regard to simple summer tomato dishes. Catch me at any time and I could declare that Panzanella is the best thing to do on the arrival of seasonal peak tomatoes. Five minutes later, I will change my air: Gazpacho. No – tuna and spanist tomato salad. Or maybe a Greek salad? Oh, but there is the classic tomato sandwich on white bread with mayonnaise.
Currently, however, my answer is the magnificently exhausted tomato and mustard pie, which means that its list of limited ingredients could imagine. That’s all I want to do this summer with my tomatoes on the farmer market, except that I also want to do all the other things that I have just shaken, and much more too. So take me to my word: this pie is the best recipe for simple summer tomatoes. And also all the others too.
Serious eats / Amanda Suarez
Basically, the recipe is incredibly simple. Any pastry crust is garnished with a generous dijon mud, then juicy red tomato bullets and just enough salt to blackmail them. It could be that, although many recipes add one thing here or there. Many include cheese, often grated Gruyère, as in this recipe, but I saw rounds of fresh goat cheese placed on top. Some give the pie a Provencal touch with stuck black olives strewn among the tomatoes. Herbs are welcome: a pinch dried with Provence herbs, as I call it here; Fresh leaves of fragrant basil scattered on top after the pie came out of the oven; Or everything that could make you happy.
Although the variations are potentially endless, I have a few notes on three specific points: pastry, mustard and salt. Everything else is quite easy to understand for yourself.
Pastry
One of the main arguments for the sale of this pie – alongside its disproportionate delicacy – is how easy it is to do. But it neglects the question of pastry – many would say that making pie or pie dough from zero is not easy, and I would not say exactly (although, with a little practice, it is not a chore). But you don’t need to make your pastry for it. One of the best approaches here is to keep a puff pastry purchased in stores in your freezer. Move it to the refrigerator to defrost, and you can have a ready pie in a few minutes.
If making your own pastry is not a great stop. Shorty pastry, a salted pie crust, is perfect, but keep in mind that you will need a pie pan for that. I know, because – in a less intelligent moment – I tried to use it for a free form cake. It is too short for any free form: it collapses, cracks and melts in a blob when it is left to support without pan.
If you want to take the cake, you are better with a classic pie crust, which can be deployed and folded on itself to form a graceful border that rocks the garnish. Or put a pie crust on a pie plate – really do what you want. This is exactly the kind of There are sections to the other Attitude, which feels exactly in the spirit of this effortless French country pie.
Matters mustard
On paper, a layer of dijon mustard may seem an excessive flavor – pungent, spicy and sharp. He was surely going to dominate the tomatoes and make you grimacted with each bite. I promise you: this is not the case. It is perfect, in a way that I cannot fully explain, except that it anchors juicy and fruity tomatoes with scented terrible acidity.
Some recipes for this pie mix the mustard with the crème fraîche to temper its intensity and add creamy. I was sure I would like to do the same, so I made a mixture of equal parts of the two and I cooked a pie with it. First of all, I must tell you that an equal mixture of Dijon and fresh cream is perhaps one of the most delicious and easiest condiments that I have ever stirred together in a small bowl. I want to eat it on everything.
But, strangely, I didn’t think it was a lot of difference. It was very tasty, but it was not tastier than mustard alone. I don’t think the pie needs it, and I don’t think you need to add the (very minor) effort to buy fresh cream for this recipe. You can if you wish, but I prefer to mack Dijon-Fraiche on almost anything else.
Salt
While developing this recipe, I had another thought: would it help pre-se the tomatoes and let them flow? I thought it would help reduce water and concentrate their flavor for better pie.
In practice, the advantage was so minor, so imperceptible, that I did not include it in the recipe, and I do not think it is necessary to wait an hour while the tomatoes are tasting and flowing before making the pie. Again, you can if you wish – it may be a little better – but I doubt that someone notes it unless you taste side by side, and even then, only if you were telling them.
But what do you know? It is the beauty of this pie. An effortless wave of the hand, a relaxed gesture in the kitchen, and this pie appears like another favorite ventilated among all the other favorites of the easy tomato for this summer and all the others.
This simple French dish is why summer tomatoes are made
Cook mode
(Keep the screen awake)
-
1 (14 ounces; 397 g) leaf puff pastry Since 1 (17.3-once) Packagelike Dufour, thawed if it is frozen; Or 1 recipe Shortcrust; Or 1/2 recipe Pie dough
-
1/4 cup (60 g)) Dijon Mustard or a mixture of equal parts of Dijon with fresh cream (see note)
-
1/4 cup packed Gruyère cheese (1 1/2 ounces; 43 g))
-
1 AVERAGE tomato (9 ounces; 255 g), caroted and sliced 1/4 thick thickness
-
Kosher salt
-
Provence herbsfor sprinkling (optional)
-
extra virgin olive oilfor the drizzle
-
Preheat the oven to 400 ° F (200 ° C) and adjust the grid in the central position.
If you use a puff pastry: on a slightly floured surface, gently confuse the puff pastry until it is large enough to line a tangy saucepan of 8 or 9 inch or a standard 9 inch pie plate, roughly the size of a 10 inch tower. Carefully transfer the mixture to a pie pan or a pie plate, pushing it gently into the edges and cut all excessive overhangs. Allow everywhere with a fork, then go to step 2.
IF Using shortcrust pastry: Follow this recipe through step 7, then go to step 2 here.
If you use the pie dough: Follow this recipe through step 3 (for slim pies crust; note that the recipe produces enough dough for 2 pies; do not hesitate to reserve the additional part for another use or a second tomato pie). Note, you can also use this style of dough for a free shape pan (see the basic technique, here shown with peaches).
-
Spread mustard on the entire base of the pie, then sprinkle with Gruyèreère everywhere.
Serious eats / Amanda Suarez
-
Arrange the tomatoes on mustard and cheese, then season with salt. Sprinkle slightly with Provence herbs (if you use) and sprinkle with olive oil.
Serious eats / Amanda Suarez
-
Bake until the tomatoes are roasted and excess water has cooked and the pastry is golden and crisp everywhere, about 30 minutes. Let cool slightly, then decide and serve.
Serious eats / Amanda Suarez
Notes
The pie is delicious with ordinary Dijon. If you wish, you can cut it with a mixture of equal parts of fresh cream, which is also delicious, although no one necessary.
Special equipment
8 -inch pie or pie plate, baking roll
Make-ahead and storage
The pastry can be prepared throughout the lining of the plates and has kept the refrigerated, wrapped in plastic, up to 1 day before filling and cooking. The pie is better assembled and cooked shortly before serving, although it can be held at room temperature up to 2 hours after cooking; Note that the longer it is, or if you wrap it in plastic, pastry can become soggy from trapped moisture. Even thus, the cooked pie can be wrapped in plastic or transferred to an airtight container and refrigerated up to 2 days; Envide the pastry on a aluminum pastry baking sheet in a hot oven before eating.


:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/GettyImages-1125588442-Westend61-5c45343599e849ecb4dc3ae574571435.jpg?w=390&resize=390,220&ssl=1)

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/20250923-SEA-20250922-SEA-MacaronaForn-NiedleCreative-HERO-b0b49638cffd41969f480fb3b24c08bf.jpg?w=390&resize=390,220&ssl=1)