The restart of Harry Potter from HBO finally has the chance to correct 1 big Hogwarts error from the movies

The original Harry Potter The films have made a clear error in Hogwarts, but the next HBO restart of the franchise can avoid repeating the same thing. Since the films have always done an incredible job to capture the tradition of the original Harry Potter Books, they deserve the merit of having preserved a large part of the magical world of JK Rowling.

At the same time, however, it cannot be denied that the films have also had their own share of defects and problems that future adaptations can now solve. No book adaptation is perfect. However, due to their limited runoff, the Harry Potter The films had to restore several original history beats, to delete them completely.

Since the capture of the words of a fantastic novel in the live narration support can always be difficult, HBO’s point of view on emblematic books will probably not be free of narrative problems. However, he can still learn a lot from everything that has gone wrong with the films to offer a refreshing and more faithful interpretation of Hogwarts.

The sorting hat was an integral part of Hogwarts

Without that, the school would not have a decisive tradition

Original belonging to Godric Gryffindor, one of the four founders of Hogwarts, sorting is an essential element in the traditions and history of Hogwarts. The legends surrounding the hat reveal that it was enchanted by the combined intelligence of the four founders, Salazar Slytherin, Rowena Ratage, Gordic Gryffindor and Helga Poufsouffle.

They created the hat to ensure that the students of the school were sorted in four houses according to the specific features that the founders wanted to see in them. The hat is also very proud to almost always place students in the house which best corresponds to their personality and their potential. In films, however, The complete extent of the goal and the intelligence of the hat remains slightly unexplored.

Harry Potter films have never represented the sorting hat

There is more in the sorting process that meets the eye

Harry Potter and the philosopher stone Seems to simplify the sorting ceremony abroad by showing how Harry convinces the hat to place it in Gryffindor even if the hat inclined more to put it in Slytherin. This seems to sell the idea that the hat uses a form of lightness to read a student’s thoughts and weigh them against his own judgment before announcing their house.

Although this is partially true, books often suggest that the hat decision -making process is much less unidimensional and also slightly defective. In books, several rhythms of history emphasize how the hat determines where a student belongs according to the personality traits, values and ambitions. However, if a student, like Harry, shows enough conviction, the hat changes your mind.

There is a sequence in novels where Dumbledore wonders if they sort too young children because he realizes that 11 -year -old children are a little too immature to achieve their moral inclinations and ambitions. He realizes that even if many students convince the hat to place them in the desired houses by showing enough conviction, these desires arise from a limited self -awareness.

In books, Dumbledore also seems to realize that the characters, like Snape, were locked in houses according to the first impressions and the influence of peers, which sealed the fate and led them on an alternative path. These contradictions rarely emerge in films, but the spectacle can finally approach them.

The Harry Potter show by HBO can finally solve sorting hat problems

The show has enough time to highlight the complexities of the sorting process

Unlike films, the show must highlight what Dumbledore thinks of the sorting process and all the problems it results. Similar to original novels, HBO’s point of view Harry Potter should also reveal that Harry was not the only character to convince the hat to place him in the desired house.

Even Hermione, as she reveals Phoenix orderCould have been in Ravegle if she had not shown enough commitment to place in Gryffindor. If the Harry Potter The show is fine, it will eventually add more emotional depth to Harry’s final interaction with his son, where he assures him that it is not in which house he is sorted, as long as his heart is in the right place.

Harry Potter

Showrunner

Francisca Gardiner

Directors

Mark mylod