The mast and peanut-beury bar that governs the Midwest potlucks
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/20250529-SEA-Scotcheroos-JatinSharma-HERO-d8c5b82b0a6e48f59626d2c1c24a0fdb.jpg?w=780&resize=780,470&ssl=1)
Why it works
- A higher ratio than usual corn syrup in sugar keeps soft and flexible bars.
- The use of brown sugar instead of white sugar amplifies the caramel caramel notes while adding humidity.
- Soft-moving coat chocolate allows a smoother lining with more balanced softness than milk chocolate chips.
In the Midwest, we blunned our heavy strikers with cute dimintes. The same goes for the Scotcheroo: an unusually soft cousin in the treat of the Krispies Rice, linked with salted peanut butter and wearing a rich layer of melted chocolate and Scottish caramel.
If you visit a coffee or a service station in the region, you are likely to see individual scotcheroos wrapped in plastic by the cash register. (In the pockets of the Upper Midwest, you will find a variant called The Special K Bar, with an exchange of ingredients that I don’t need to explain.) But Scotcheroos is really more a community dish than a commercial dish. I grew up eating them in potlucks and concession stands – the place where you might need to satisfy a crowd with some cheap ingredients.
Serious eats / Jatin Sharma
The Scotcheroos are simple, but they can be surprisingly capricious. Most recipes start with a cooked sugar syrup which is a 50/50 right division of corn syrup and granulated sugar. The problem? If you boil the syrup just too long – or tap the bars in place with just a little too much punch – your tapes will harden in candies.
Understanding just a little science behind this sugar can help you build a more resilient roo. The advice below contribute to the infallible formula, preserving the classic peanut flavor profile of the Scotchero, chocolate and caramel flavor profile without tastes, awkwardly.
The 3 rules for infallible roos
1. hang on to the corn (syrup). There is no way to get around this: corn syrup is the simplest way to a very exhilarating scotcherororo. At the start of the tests, I tried to replace corn syrup with other liquid sweeteners with universal disappointment. Maple syrup has led to fried bars with little cohesion; Honey diverted the classic flavor profile and made the bars too sweet. Liquid release sweeteners made the Scotcheroos Rock completely.
There is a reason why confectioners have used corn syrup for decades. Corn syrup, unlike other sweeteners, has extra-long glucose chains that prevent crystallization and lend the body and mast of candies.
There is also a reason why most Scotchero recipes cut the corn syrup with granulated sugar. Too much corn syrup gives bars that are both too soft and also – well, well, worn out, in the commercialized industrial sense. I played with different reports, but a 60/40 distribution of the sugar corn syrup gave a more soft and more flexible bar without alteration of notable flavor.
2. Replace the white sugar with brown sugar. While most of Scotchero recipes call for granulated sugar, brown sugar has advantages of both texture and flavor here. The brown sugar molasses stimulates the caramel notes of the bars, giving a roo that has more taste. This also adds to the humidity content of sugar, offering additional insurance against an overly crunchy bar.
3. Combine your Scottish caramel with a bit of bitter chocolate. If you are only ready to make one adjustment to the box recipe in the background, it should be this: Chop your chocolate. Chocolate with chopped bar melts much more uniformly than chocolate chips. It is the secret of a versable garnish that looks shiny and smooth. I also recommend using soft -amer chocolate to help temper the disgusting sweetness of butter – look at a 60% cocoa bar.
The only remaining tip is an optional pinch of laminated sea salt, like Maldon, on the garnish before its whole. Of course, it is a slightly difficult touch for the humble Scotchero. But there is another Midwest lesson here: it is not because it is simple that it must be clear.
Serious eats / Jatin Sharma
How to make scotcheroos: the bar-Beury-Beury with peanuts that governs the Midwest potlucks
Cook mode
(Keep the screen awake)
-
Cooking spray To grease the pan
-
1 1/4 cup light corn syrup (11 1/2 ounces; 324 g), Like Karo
-
7 1/2 ounces brown off (215 g; about 3/4 cup Vaguely wrapped)
-
9 ounces (255 g; 1 cup)) creamy peanut butter
-
2 teaspoon (10 ml)) vanilla extract
-
1 teaspoon (4 g)) Crystal Diamond Salt Casher; For table salt, use about half as much volume or the same weight
-
6 cups (180 g)) Crispy rice cereals Like Krispie rice
-
8 ounces (225 g)) caramel
-
8 ounces (225 g)) Soft-man chocolate60% cocoa, roughly chopped
-
Plasted sea saltLike Maldon, to finish, optional
-
Lightly grease a 9 by 13 inch mold with a cooking spray; Cancel. In a minimum saucepan of 3 -quarter oven or a Dutch oven, heat the corn syrup and sugar over medium heat, whisking from time to time, until the mixture simply boils on the edges, about 2 minutes.
Serious eats / Jatin Sharma
-
Slowly enter the peanut butter, vanilla and kosher salt until the peanut butter is completely incorporated and the mixture is smooth, about 30 seconds more.
Serious eats / Jatin Sharma
-
Halan, bend in rice cereals with a rubber spatula. Transfer the mixture to the greased saucepan and type gently in place (do not surpass).
Serious eats / Jatin Sharma
-
In a heat-resistant bowl, melt the chocolate and microwave caramel chips at 15-30 seconds intervals, stirring carefully between each interval, until they are brilliant and smooth. Pour on the cereals and use rubber spatulas to spread the garnish on the bars in a thin and uniform layer. Sprinkle with sectional salt on the garnish, if you wish.
Serious eats / Jatin Sharma
-
Let the scatchéroos stand at room temperature for at least 2 hours or until the garnish is firm and set. Cut into squares of about 2 inches and serve.
Serious eats / Jatin Sharma
Special equipment
3-qt cap or Dutch oven, 9 by 13 inch cooking carrots, rubber spatula
Notes
To further improve the melasse notes from the bars, you can replace up to 1/4 cup of clear corn syrup for dark corn syrup or cane syrup. The flavor profile will be less traditional, but absolutely delicious.
Make-ahead and storage
Storped in an airtight container, not cut tapes can be kept up to 7 days at room temperature. To keep the bars soft, closely wrap all the bars cut individually in a plastic film.

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/20240418-SEA-Lemon-Tart-AmandaSuarez-hero2-5808e7667177400486366bedc6c4323b.jpg?w=390&resize=390,220&ssl=1)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/sea-mothers-day-gift-guide-tout-9c1d581421e94152bfdff66adb796555.jpg?w=390&resize=390,220&ssl=1)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/20241101-SEA-AppleFritters-RobbyLozano_Hero1-12-d5be39677bbe4b85aa133e72fb587983.jpg?w=390&resize=390,220&ssl=1)
