Snicko controversy: Alex Carey responds after operator admits ‘human error’ on first day of Adelaide test | Ashes 2025-26
Alex Carey delivered a memorable performance on the first day of 3rd Ashes Test in Adelaidescoring a brilliant counter-attacking 106 to restore momentum in Australia’s favor after an early batting collapse. The wicketkeeper’s innings not only revived the hosts but also became the center of a major DRS controversy that sparked a debate late in the day.
Arriving with Australia under pressure, Carey showed composure and intent, combining precise kicking and calculated aggression. His century proved crucial in stabilizing the innings and frustrating England’s bowlers on a day that otherwise belonged to the visitors from the start.
DRS drama overshadows Alex Carey’s century
England review denied despite Snicko’s whisper
Carey’s move was not without controversy, however. During their innings, England appealed for a dismissal taken after a delivery of Josh tonguewith wicketkeeper Jamie Smith also convinced that there was a benefit. On-field umpire Ahsan Raza rejected the appeal, prompting England to opt for a review.
As Snicko made a slight sound, the third official ruled that the ball had not passed close enough to the stick to confirm an advantage. As a result, Carey was granted a reprieve – a decision which visibly frustrated England.
Controversy in #TheCendres while a human error with Snicko saves Alex Carey… and his century 👀 pic.twitter.com/VXxqmNPb6N
– Cricket on TNT Sports (@cricketontnt) December 17, 2025
Alex Carey admits he hit the ball
The debate intensified after Carey’s press conference, during which the Australian admitted that he had indeed touched the ball during the disputed throw.
“I thought there was a little feather or some sort of noise when it passed in front of the bat,” » said Carey. “If it had been given to me, I think I would have looked at it. Probably not with confidence though. It was a nice sound when it went off the bat.”
Carey’s frank admission fueled discussions about the accuracy and reliability of the decision review system in high-stakes Test matches.
BBG Sports accepts responsibility for Snicko’s mistake
Technology provider BBG Sports, which operates the Snickometer system, later admitted that human error was responsible for the poor decision. In a statement released to BBC Sport, the company explained that the wrong microphone was selected during audio processing.
“Given that Alex Carey admitted to hitting the ball in question, the only conclusion that can be drawn is that Snicko’s operator at the time selected the wrong stump mic,” » reads the statement. “In light of this, BBG Sports takes full responsibility for this error.”
Also READ: Ashes 2025/26 – Fans erupt as Alex Carey lights up Adelaide Oval with magnificent ton on first day of third Test
The microphone used would come from the non-attacking side, resulting in inaccurate audio interpretation.
DRS protocols under surveillance during the WTC match
Host broadcaster provides review technology
The incident once again put DRS protocols under the microscope, particularly in World Test Championship (WTC) matches where the system is mandatory. For the Adelaide Test, testing technology was provided by host broadcaster, Fox Cricket, in accordance with ICC regulations.
Although the error did not violate playing conditions, it raised concerns about operational controls and the margin for error in crucial moments of elite cricket.
Also WATCH: Zak Crawley takes a one-handed blinder to dismiss Travis Head on day one of the Adelaide Test
